The Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List – The Best of the Shore

The Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List – The Best of the Shore

We are self-proclaimed Jersey Shore foodies here at Jersey Shore In Motion. If there’s a sandwich, pizza, pasta, burger, or any kind of dish worth noting, we’re on it. Gathering our information from our own foodie knowledge, fellow locals, and word of mouth, we’ve compiled what we proclaim as the ultimate Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List. These are the best of the best food experiences in Monmouth & Ocean Counties, and we dare you to go enjoy each and every one of them.

The Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List

(listed alphabetically)

Spaghetti & Meatballs at Ama Ristorante
Every Tuesday night in the off season, Ama Ristorante Sea Bright has one of our favorite specials at the shore; unlimited spaghetti & meatballs for $15. Their bottles of wine are also 1/2 off! 1485 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright (732) 530-9760

Pretzel and Kaese-Krainer Wuerste at Asbury Festhalle & Biergarten
Satisfying even the most discerning carnivore, the Kaese-Krainer Wuerste at Asbury Festhalle & Biergarten is a savory combination of mildly smoked pork and beef sausage filled with cheese. Pair your Austrian sausage with the pretzel that outsizes all others and a German bier for a Jersey Shore foodie experience that’s got some German spirit. 527 Lake Avenue, Asbury Park (732) 997-8767

Lobster Boil for Two at Beach Tavern
Indulge in a seafood feast at Beach Tavern with a loved one! Boiled lobster, shrimp, clams and mussels make up a seafood boil that is guaranteed to please the seafood lover in you – and your date. If you’re not in the mood to share, it’s Lobster Thursday every Thursday. Enjoy a 1 lbs broiled or steamed lobster with Old Bay fries. 33 West St, Monmouth Beach (732) 870-8999

Crackling Calamari Salad at The Bistro at Red Bank
One of our favorite salads anywhere! Bistro’s crackling calamari salad is a perfect blend of flavors. The Asian inspired calamari, with black sesame seeds and a spicy miso lime dressing it all harmoniously comes together in salad bliss! 14 Broad Street, Red Bank (732) 530-5553

Crab Cakes at Blend On Main
When you dine at Blend On Main, always get the crab cake appetizer. We’re telling you, definitely order other things, but Blend On Main’s signature crab cake recipe with roasted corn and mango and a drizzle of lemon aioli has us dreaming of summer all year long. 152 Main Street, Manasquan (732) 223-0030

Trio of Chowders at The Bonney Read
They may be three separate dishes, but each one deserves its righteous place on your dinner plate. The Bonney Read specializes in everything chowder from the traditional creamy New England Clam Chowder with hints of bacon to the sassy Lobster Bisque with licorice fennel, sherry, and chives, to the not so classic “Jersey Green” Clam Chowder featuring green peppers, fennel, and sausage… yes, sausage These chowders are Jersey Shore foodie classics in the making. 533 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park (732) 455-3352

Barnegat Light Scallops and Peppered Bacon at Chef Mike’s Atlantic Bar & Grill
When the Barnegat Light Scallops are on special at Chef Mike’s Atlantic Bar & Grill, they’re an absolute must order. Chef Mike cooks the scallops to perfection and if you sit at the bar with a cocktail and snack on their peppered bacon – it’s foodie heaven. 24th & Central Avenue, South Seaside Park (732) 854-1588

Charcuterie Platter at The Cheese Cave
Known for their array of cheese boards, cured meats, and “sandwicheeses,” it’s hard to pick out a favorite at The Cheese Cave. But, if you’re looking to complete the Jersey Shore foodie bucket list, the Charcuterie Platter is up next. A true meat lover’s delight, this board is full with Finnochiona, Sopressata, Coppa Piccanta, and Prosciutto, all complemented by a random rotation of roasted peppers, mixed olives, almonds or figs. 14 Monmouth Street, Red Bank (732) 842-0796

Short Ribs at Dish Restaurant
We may have Chef Anthony Ferrando’s recipe for Dish Restaurant’s infamous Short Ribs up on our site, but no matter how many times we try, nothing beats the real deal. These succulent short ribs have become the starring role of many of our cravings and we hope this staple dish never leaves the menu. 13 White Street, Red Bank (732) 345-7070

Tijuana Tuesday Tacos at Dive
One of the places to be every Tuesday is Dive in Sea Bright for their Tijuana Tuesday, aka surf night. There’s drink specials, art exhibits, live music, but most importantly – the tacos! In the past, we’ve experienced incredible tacos like: grilled hangar steak tacos, soft shelled crab tacos, shrimp tacos & many more. 1072 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright (732) 268-7707

Voodoo Shrimp at Drew’s Bayshore Bistro
Chef/Owner Drew Araneo has racked up countless accolades for his Bistro in Keyport. We’ve always enjoyed our meals there, but we always come back to one dish; Voodoo Shrimp. The dish that beat Bobby Flay! 25 Church Street, Keyport (732) 739-9219

Yeero & Village Fries at Greek Eats
Not even open a year yet, Greek Eats is making a big splash in the greater Red Bank area. Their fast casual concept allows you to build your own Yeero (gyro) or Greek Salad in a Chipotle style assembly line. It’s brilliant! Start with angus beef, chicken, pork or bifteki and have fun with the toppings; Greek chimichuri, sriracha tzatziki, feta, kalmata olives, cucumber, pickled onions, tomatoes and much more. Just remember to order the village fries. 89 Newman Springs Road, Shrewsbury (732) 530-0777

Italian Sub with Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Petals at Joe Leone’s
Start off with the fresh bread, go for all the fixings with your favorite Italian meats, add some fresh mozzarella and roasted tomato petals, and you’ve got a sandwich that may seem simple, but when all the ingredients are just right, it becomes legendary. And it’s only the Italian sub, only at Joe Leone’s. 510 Route 35 South, PointPleasant Beach (732) 701-0001

Sunday Brunch at the Molly Pitcher Inn
We’ve said it before – there is no brunch that can compare to Red Bank’s historical Molly Pitcher Inn. We’re talking fresh waffles, crepes, steaks, oysters and clams, lamb, and of course all of your traditional fixings. Combine these dishes with the sweeping views of the Navesink River and a cocktail and you’re in for a treat. 88 Riverside Avenue, Red Bank (732) 747-2500

Pollo Milanese at Panini Bay
Sometimes what seems to be a “simple dish” tastes like a stellar dish, especially when it’s prepared to perfection. The Pollo Milanese at Panini Bay is a prime example. A crunchy and moist chicken cutlet served simply with slow roasted plum tomatoes, and a salad of crisp romaine lettuce, all dressed with lemon and extra virgin olive oil. It’s a classic that will never go out of style. 101 Parker Road, Tuckerton (609) 294-4281

Double Cut Stuffed Pork Chop at Patricia’s
With an vast variety of Italian restaurants in the area the competition is stiff. One bite of the Double Stuffed Pork Chop over fresh beet risotto from Patricia’s and you’ll quickly realize that this restaurant to your list of regular haunts. 2132 NJ-35, Holmdel (732) 275-0234

Family Style Dinner at Patrizia’s of Red Bank
The 8 – 10 course family style is a fest for the ages! It’s an onslaught of one delicious course after another, served in Patrizia’s dramatic dining room. We’d say to make sure you save room for dessert, but it’s nearly impossible, yet somehow we always find a way. It’s a a great way to bring family or friends together for an unforgettable feast. 28 Broad Street, Red Bank (732) 741-5555

Pork Osso Bucco at Porcini
This hidden gem hasn’t been open long, but the buzz has been quickly building. Chef/owner Chris Atamian’s take on short pork osso bucco is one of the best at the shore. Porcini serves them with a sweet potato hash, garlic broccoli rabe and in a maple-whisky sauce. 168 Bay Avenue, Highlands (732) 291-3080

Cocoa/Pepper Beef Carpaccio at Remington’s The Restaurant
Even if raw meat is not your thing, don’t hesitate to order the Cocoa/Pepper Beef Carpaccio at Remington’s The Restaurant. A beautiful salad of toasted pumpernickel, celery, and arugula is served atop thinly sliced beef, then sprinkled with Parmigiano, Sicilian sea salt, and a meyer lemon-black truffle vinaigrette. It’s fancy and oh so tasty. 142 Main Street, Manasquan (732) 292-1300

Raw Bar at Rooney’s Oceanfront Restaurant
With one of the best views in New Jersey, Rooney’s in Long Branch is also one of the best seafood houses at the shore. Their fresh fish board is absolutely outstanding, but their raw bar is off the charts! It’s easily some of the best raw oysters, peel and eat shrimp, and clams we’ve ever had. 100 Ocean Avenue North, Long Branch (732) 870-1200

Ravioli ai Funghi at Senza
Senza is our definition of hidden gem. We heard the rave reviews and in every trip to Senza, we’ve been impressed! our favorite has to be the homemade pasta, and especially the wild mushroom stuffed ravioli served in a fresh tomato mushroom sauce with a touch of cream. 333 Atlantic City Avenue, Bayville (732) 503-4470

Short Ribs at Taka
People rave about the fresh & creative sushi at Taka, but there’s a little secret that only a select few know; the short ribs may just be the best thing on the menu! We were once given the same but of advice and sure enough, its true! 660 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park 732-775-1020

 Sizzling Black Pepper Filet Mignon at Temple Gourmet Chinese
When we say this dish is sizzling, we mean it and not just because it’s actually sizzling when it’s served to you at Temple Gourmet Chinese, but because it has made it into our sizzle reel of the top Jersey Shore foodie experiences. It may very well be the best filet mignon at the shore! 91 Broad Street, Red Bank (732) 212-8858

Spinach, Feta & Mushroom Omelette at Toast
With two locations at the shore (Asbury Park & Red Bank), as well as one in Montclair, Toast is rapidly becoming one of the state’s premier breakfast & lunch spots. The spinach, feta & mushroom omelette is a breakfast treat! It’s served with potatoes and toast. (Make the upgrade to the biscuit and thank us later.) A close second is their Huevos Rancheros. It’s one of the best Huevos we’ve ever had! 516 Cookman Ave, Asbury Park (732) 776-5900 & 45 Monmouth St, Red Bank (732) 224-1234

Mussels and Pork Chops at Trama’s Trattoria
The Famous Original Mussels from Trama’s Trattoria are famous for a reason. Served with toasted garlic, tomato gravy (yes, it’s gravy at Trama’s, not sauce), and fresh Brooklyn bread for scraping up those juices, you can see what we mean. Go for a double and order the Pork Chop served with creamy Mascarpone polenta, agri dolce cippollini onion, and oven roasted asparagus. 115 Brighton Avenue, Long Branch (732) 222-1121

The Dare Burger at Tuscan Bistro Bar
Every Thursday, Tuscan Bistro Bar invites their customers to take the ultimate challenge and order the Dare Burger. Tell them how you like it cooked and how spicy you want it, but the rest is up to the chef. He’ll whip up a one-of-a-kind burger that’s made just for you. It’s a unique dining experience that is sure to impress and give you a little adrenaline rush! 1250 Hooper Avenue, Toms River (732) 797-2570

 Chef’s Table at GRAZE
To sit at the Chef’s Table at GRAZE is to experience a dinner that will blow your senses away. Chef Laercio Chamon, Jr. aka Junior invites you and 11 of your closest friends to one of a kind dinner featuring anything and everything from locally raised suckling pig to freshly caught tuna in this behind the scenes culinary experience. 151 Markham Place, Little Silver (732) 747-9988