The Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List: 19 Ice Cream Cones, Sundaes, and Italian Ice to Devour

The Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List: 19 Ice Cream Cones, Sundaes, and Italian Ice to Devour

Summer is here and we’re celebrating that fact with a special Jersey Shore Ice Cream Edition of our Jersey Shore Foodie Bucket List. We weren’t just thinking about the best soft serve at the Jersey Shore – we’re talking about outrageous (and absolutely delicious) ice cream sundaes, cones, flavors, and combinations (as well as a few can’t miss places that have become the epitome of a quality day out in the sun (clouds, rain, snow, you name it).

Think of our ultimate list of Jersey Shore ice cream as something to go through bite by heavenly creamy bite. Whether you’re enjoying three scoops (waffle, toppings, you name it) by yourself or taking a bunch of spoons and sharing it with friends, ice cream is the ultimate spring and summer comfort food.

So let’s here it – I scream, you scream, we all scream for some delicious Jersey Shore ice cream!

A Jersey Shore Local’s Guide to the Chillest Ice Cream in Monmouth and Ocean Counties

Jersey Freeze – Freehold & Holmdel

In Freehold, it’s all about the freeze, Jersey Freeze. Since 1952, they’ve been crafting up simple to exceptional ice cream contraptions that will make your summer (fall, winter, and spring) days much sweeter. If you can, find a reason to order one of their famous Shakes of the Month or take some of their frozen treats home with you. 120 Manalapan Ave, Freehold (732) 462-3008

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice – North Middletown, Union Beach

Every day is a Sundae at Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice! Offering a wide variety of small-batch ice cream flavors, Frozen Flavors listens to their customer’s ideas and transforms them into a special and unforgettable experience. Milkshakes, sundaes, pints, ice cream sandwiches, homemade cones, gelatis, Jordinis and much more are part of a wide variety of their parlor’s favorites. Scooping every day until 10pm! 490 Palmer Ave, North Middletown 848-256-8266

CRAZEES – Rumson

A landmark in the Rumson community, there’s never a night where you won’t find kids, families, and really adults at Crazees in Rumson. Everything is delicious, their dipped sugar cones take the cake, and so do their colorful fruitful flavors. 2 W River Road, Rumson 732-530-6543

Cookman Creamery – Asbury Park

Calling all Jersey Shore ice cream lovers who don’t eat traditional dairy! At Cookman Creamery they make the real deal – whether it’s traditional ice cream with milk or vegan featuring a creamy coconut cream base. One of their newest flavors, Blueberry Biscoff, hits all the right notes with organic coconut cream based vegan ice cream with homemade blueberry purée, swirled with Biscoff cookies. 711 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park 732-361-5215

Strollo’s Lighthouse – Long Branch, Belmar, Red Bank

No guide to the best Jersey Shore ice cream would be complete with a shout out to The Lighthouse. With a number of locations along the shore (Red Bank, Long Branch, Belmar) there’s no reason to not stop by and get a swirl – a creamy, homemade Italian ice (we’re fallen hard for mango when it’s available) that sits next to an even creamier soft serve of vanilla. Sprinkles are (not) optional. 250 Ocean Avenue N, Long Branch 732-229-1222

Rich’s Ice Cream – Toms River

Three generations and 60 years later, the ice cream bars at Rich’s Ice Cream are just one of the many reasons that people keep coming back again and again. For a blow-your-mind-experience, go for the Ritchie Bar where you’ll enjoy chocolate or vanilla ice cream that’s snuggled between a crispy wafer and chocolate pieces (exactly like those found on your favorite ice cream cake). You’re welcome. 1801 Rt. 37 East, Toms River 732-349-3459

Hoffman’s Ice Cream – Point Pleasant

Since 1955, Hoffman’s Ice Cream has grown into a Jersey Shore ice cream classic. Four locations and dozens of flavors later, all their ice cream is still made in their original location. Whether you’re getting a coffee ice cream on a cone, picking up an ice cream cake, or maybe going for the shake with sprinkles, you’ll definitely be eating one of the “very best.” 800 Richmond Avenue, Pt. Pleasant Beach 732-892-0270

Ralph’s Italian Ice & Ice Cream – Lanoka Harbor, Toms River, Asbury Park

It only took one season for everyone to figure out that an ice could be so much more than what you’re used to. Instead of just, well, ice, Ralph’s Italian Ice brings you big flavors in creamy ices that include flavors like Vanilla Peanut Butter, Chocolate Marshmallow and Spumoni. Of course there’s also all of your favorite water ice flavors like lemon, blue hawaii, and mango too. We can’t choose so we just pick both! 349 N Main St, Lanoka Harbor 609 242-8006

Coney Waffle – Belmar, Long Branch, Asbury Park, Red Bank

If you’ve ever done a double take at a crazy ice cream shake or cone, chances are high that it came from Coney Waffle. For us, we’re always down for a Crazy Shake, where they take a large shake with your choice of ice cream and pile it high with cotton candy, chocolate covered pretzels and assorted candy pieces. 800 Ocean Avenue, Asbury Park 732-556-6951

Days Ice Cream – Ocean Grove

Set in one of the Jersey Shore’s most idyllic town is one of the Jersey Shore’s most idyllic ice cream store. Over 140 years and counting, Day’s Ice Cream serves up a variety of flavors that will cure any ice cream meltdown. Even though we love to enjoy a cone of hard ice cream out on the deck, we also are suckers for their ice cream covered waffles that strike the perfect balance between adult and childhood. 48 Pitman Avenue, Ocean Grove 732-614-6245

Ryan’s Home Made Ice Cream – Shrewsbury

You’ve driven by it more times than you can count and if you’re one of the ice cream lovers in the know, then you’ve stopped into Ryan’s Home Made Ice Cream countless times as well. When you order, make sure it’s whatever they have on special (you’ll see it on the board out front). It’s limited time and you’ll want to make the most out of it! Oh and it doesn’t matter if you want to eat the ice cream now or later when you pick up some of their ice cream to go. 462 Shrewsbury Avenue, Shrewsbury 732-842-5874

Skipper Dipper – LBI

Looking for the best place for ice cream on Long Beach Island? Skipper Dipper has been LBI’s favorite since 1978, offering hard and soft ice cream, shakes, sundaes, ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches, Dole Whip and dairy-free vegan choices. 9305 Long Beach Blvd, Beach Haven 609-492-9680

Kohr’s – Seaside Heights Boardwalk

Yes, this is an ice cream article, but we’re throwing in some frozen custard because a list about ice cream at the Jersey Shore can’t be complete without a shout out to Kohr’s The Original. Even though you can order ice cream, we prefer the Swirled Frozen Custard – orange cream with strawberry, black cherry with chocolate, or even raspberry with cool mint – it’s the cherry to a summer day! Franklin Ave on the Boardwalk, Seaside Heights

Stromberg’s – Seaside Park

This spring, one of the best Jersey Shore ice cream stores is opening again for their 3rd season. They may be a newer shop, but locals (and pretty much anyone that’s visited the Jersey Shore) knows that Stromberg’s of Midway’s ice cream is truly one of a kind thanks to the countless toppings that they offer. We’re fans of their cookie dough topped with cannoli cream and hot fudge. 39 11th Lane, Seaside Park

Nicholas Creamery – Atlantic Highlands, Long Branch, Tinton Falls, Fair Haven, Middletown

Nicholas Creamery was born out of a love for homemade ice cream, handcrafted recipes and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form. They hand-make small batch ice cream and ice cream cakes using the purest of ingredients and collaborate with local businesses to showcase the best products in New Jersey. Every week, a new flavor pops up for locals to try at their five locations in Long Branch, Atlantic Highlands, Tinton Falls, Fair Haven and Middletown! 84 1st Ave, Atlantic Highlands 732-204-2340

Ice Cream Boss – Seaside Park

Drive down Central Ave on your way home from Island Beach State Park and be sure to stop at the Ice Cream Boss in Seaside Park. A true “Mom n’ Pop Shop” they serve everything from ice cream cones and floats to what we really want to get, their hot brownie sundae. Choose your flavors, add some toppings, and cool off after a day in the sun. 10 NE Central Ave, Seaside Park 732-250-2002, IceCreamBossNJ

Betty’s Icebox – Asbury Park Boardwalk

Proudly featuring healthier versions of boardwalk classic treats, Betty’s Icebox offers Hawaiian style shave ice, gourmet ice pops made on site, house made shaved ice cream, vegan soft serve, ice cream sandwiches, edible cookie dough, chocolate covered bananas and much more! Vegan, gluten free, peanut free, dairy free, dye free options are always available! Asbury Park Convention Center 732-927-0633

Main Scoop Creamery – Manasquan

Main Scoop Creamery offers a wide variety of treats to make everyone smile. From premium homemade ice cream, dairy-free and vegan flavors, gelato, sorbet, and Italian ice, to sugar-free options and cakes, you’ll leave with your sweet tooth satisfied. The patio is also pet-friendly, so feel free to bring your pups along – they even have treats for them too! 140 b Main St, Manasquan 732-223-3594

Chuck’s Ice Cream – Toms River

If you’re looking for Italian Ice with a view, then Chuck’s Ice Cream truck is your spot. Located in the Mathis Plaza, right across from the River Lady, Chuck’s is serving up everything from all your favorite flavors of Italian Ice to Burgers, Cheesesteaks and Fries from April – October. Stop by, hang out at the picnic tables and take in the views of the Toms River. 134 NJ 166, Toms River

Let us know what your favorite Ice Cream spots are and if there’s a business you think we should add!

Interested in signing up with Jersey Shore InMotion? Let us know HERE!