Best Of

Eating and Drinking Our Way Through These Jersey Shore Fall Menus + Deals!

When the leaves start to fall, football games take up our Sundays, and our flannels become a mainstay in our closets, it can only mean one thing – Autumn. What makes this season even better is the food. Full of butternut squash, gamey meat, fresh seafood, and pumpkins… lots and lots of pumpkins, Autumn is a season we can get behind. Celebrate the harvest along with some of our favorite Jersey Shore fall menus to welcome the flavors of fall. Whether you’re in the mood for some squash, a tasty seafood dish, sweets, or some cocktails, it’s a fall flavor feast for the senses.

Fallin’ For These Cocktails

Kentucky Bourbon at Rooney’s Oceanfront Restaurant, Long Branch

Rooney’s Oceanfront Restaurant has answered the age-old question – what drink should I have with dinner? Their Smoked Old Fashioned answers that question perfectly. Made with Buffalo Trace Distillery’s rich and smooth Kentucky Bourbon and crushed orange and cherry, this is the ultimate Fall drink. 100 Ocean Ave N, Long Branch, 732-870-1200 http://www.rooneysocean.com

Cozy Cocktails at Oyster Creek Inn, Leeds Point

We’re falling for Oyster Creek’s Cozy Cocktail menu! Featuring all the flavors that go hand in hand with the Autumn season, order up a Pumpkin Spice Espresso Martini, Salted Caramel Martini, or a Caramel Apple Mule while taking in the gorgeous marsh views. 41 Oyster Creek Rd, Leeds Point, 609-652-8565 http://www.oystercreekinnnj.com

Booker’s The Reserves & Monmouth Goes South at TAKA Restaurant, Asbury Park

Taka in Asbury Park dishes out the best sushi you’ll find on Cookman Ave. This Fall, pair your favorite rolls with the Booker’s The Reserves 2024 batch. An extremely rare expression aged for 8 years, 2 months and 12 days with a proof of 127.8. Also on the menu is the Monmouth Goes South cocktail made with Laird’s Apple Jack, Chicha Morada Liquor and Apple Cider. Put them on your Fall Cocktail list and next time you’re in Asbury, take a stop into Taka. 660 Cookman Ave, Asbury Park, 732-775-1020 https://www.takaasbury.com/ 

Soup Season

Sweet Potato Smoked Chili Bisque & Crab Bisque at Porcini, Highlands

Soup season is in full swing at Porcini Italian Trattoria in the Highlands. When the temperatures start to drop and there’s a chill in the air, you can count on their Sweet Potato Smoked Chili Bisque and the Crab Bisque to warm you up. These soups are Jersey Shore fall menu items with strong Italian roots. For a look at their fall menu, visit http://www.restaurantporcini.com/menus. 168 Bay Ave, Highlands, 732-291-3080

Manhattan Clam Chowder & New England Clam Chowder at Klein’s Fish Market, Belmar

As the weather cools down, soup season turns up at Klein’s Fish in Belmar! From Manhattan Clam Chowder to New England Clam Chowder, Klein’s only serves the best. Their fish market is also open all year round, so after dining in, stop into the market and bring some fresh fish home. 708 River Rd, Belmar, 732-681-1177 https://kleinsfish.com/

Brunch With Us

MJ’s in Matawan serves up a warm and delicious Brunch every Sunday from 11am to 4pm. Some menu items include, the Boozy French Toast, Huevos Rancheros, Supersized Stack of Pancake, Breakfast Burritos and more. No Brunch is complete without a cocktail so how about trying an MJ’s Mimosa, Bloody Mary, Sangria or Boozy Coffee?! Call 732-566-6220 to make a Brunch Reservation. 845 Route 34, Matawan, 732-566-6220 https://www.mjsrestaurant.com/Matawan/

Comfort Food

Gluten Free Pizza & Lobster Tail, Pazzo MMX, Red Bank

Nothing says comfort food on a chilly day quite like a nice cheesy pizza. Pazzo MMX in Red Bank makes it easy to enjoy your favorites at a discounted price! Their long-running special for 1/2 off Pizza and Pasta items runs every Monday from 3PM to close, so order up one of their pies or if you’re feeling daring, the Lobster Tail! 141 W Front St, Red Bank, 732-747-4551 https://www.pazzoredbank.com/

Orecchiette & Rigatoni at Trama’s Trattoria, Long Branch

The fall menu at Trama’s Trattoria is filled with winners, but we have to say Chef Pat outdid himself with the pasta dishes on the menu this fall. Try the Orecchiette with broccoli rabe, toasted garlic, red pepper flakes, Parmesan Reggiano or the Rigatoni with Italian sweet sausage, English peas, San Marzano plum tomatoes, parmesan cream. Pair it with one of their fall cocktails and it’s a night out that you’ll be reminiscing about for quite some time. 115 Brighton Ave, Long Branch, 732-222-1121 http://www.tramastrattoria.com

Spicy Rigatoni & Red Wine Braised Short Rib at The Atlantic House

The just-launched Fall menu at The Atlantic House is full of enticing dishes like the Spicy Rigatoni with Sweet Italian Sausage Crumble. They also added the Tender Slow cooked Red Wine Braised Short Rib on a bed of Creamy Yukon Gold Mashed in our Distinctive Pan Au Jus. You just can’t go wrong at The Atlantic House. 67 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, 848-300-2408 https://www.theatlantichousenj.com/

Chicken Pot Pie at Molly Pitcher Inn, Red Bank

How can you make Chicken Pot Pie even better? Serve it the way the Molly Pitcher Inn does in their dining room with panoramic views of the Navesink. Their famous pot pie puts a new spin on the classic dish, but is always fresh, warm and ready to eat. 88 Riverside Ave, Red Bank, 732-747-2500 http://www.themollypitcher.com

Sweet Potato Bisque & Pork Belly & Sprouts at Drew’s Bayshore Bistro, Keyport

Drew’s Bayshore Bistro puts out innovative and one-of-a-kind dishes every season of the year, but Fall is where it’s at for Drew’s. The Sweet Potato Bisque and the Pork Belly & Sprouts with Pork Cracklins, Brussel Sprouts, Toasted Pumpkin Seed and Tabasco Gastrique are warm, packed with flavor, and just what you need on a cold Fall night. 25 Church St, Keyport, 732-739-9219 http://drewsbayshorebistro.com/

Steakhouse Burger & Espresso Martini at Pearl at Oyster Point Hotel, Red Bank

Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel updates their menu whenever the seasons change and now it’s tastier than ever! One menu item to try this Fall is the Steakhouse Burger with black angus chuck, brisket and short rib, peppered bacon, sharp cheddar and onion rings. Wash down dinner with the Espresso Martini. Reserve a table now by calling 732-530-8200! 146 Bodman Pl, Red Bank https://www.theoysterpointhotel.com/

Coal Fired Pizza & Steak Frites Night at Urban Coalhouse, Red Bank

Urban Coalhouse’s authentic coal-fired pizza is always cooked to perfection in their 800-degree coal-fired oven. A fresh pie is nothing short of ideal Fall comfort food. Dine in for lunch or dinner or stop in on Saturday’s for Steak Frites Night featuring NY Strip Steak, Greens and Fries for only $35. 2 Bridge Avenue, Red Bank, 732-212-1700 https://urbancoalhouse.com/

Grandma’s Turkey Sandwich Special, The Pour House, Tinton Falls

What’s better than a Thanksgiving dinner feast? When it comes in the form of a sandwich! The Pour House’s Grandma’s Turkey Sandwich Special is the ultimate comfort food. It’s put together with Turkey topped with house-made cranberry sauce, stuffing, and pan gravy on French bread, served with mashed potatoes. 640 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls, 732-842-4337 https://www.pourhouserestaurant.com/

Fall Catering

Fall Catering & Football Packages at Mutiny BBQ, Asbury Park

The height of Mutiny BBQ’s Summer catering season is over and they now have availability for parties big and small through the fall season! Mutiny BBQ also has Football Packages available to feed all your friends and family members on Sundays. There are Wing Trays, Pork, and Brisket Combos, and Rib Feast packages available, so order ahead of time and do game days right. 808 Fifth Ave, Asbury Park, 732-366-9985 https://www.mutinybbq.com/

Sweet Treats

Apple Pie Ice Cream & Iced Coffee Gelati at Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice, Middletown

On top of their extensive list of Ice Creams, Italian Ice, and Shake flavors, Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream and Italian Ice has one heck of a Fall frozen treat menu. The Apple Pie Ice Cream has the perfect amount of that apple pie flavor you’ve been craving and the Iced Coffee Gelati has enough Vanilla Ice Cream and Iced Coffee Italian Ice to make it a Fall favorite! 490 Palmer Ave, North Middletown, 848-256-8266 https://frozenflavorswebsi.wixsite.com/my-site

Apple Cider Donut Shake at Jersey Freeze, Freehold & Holmdel

Jersey Freeze has been a New Jersey Ice Cream Shop staple in Freehold since 1952 and in Holmdel at Bell Works since 2020. New Jersey residents travel near and far to try their specialty, handmade ice cream and look forward to the 1st of every month when they announce their Shake of the Month. This Fall, head to Jersey Freeze for the Apple Cider Donut Shake, take home some of their to-go desserts, or indulge in their famous soft serve! 101 Crawfords Corner Rd Holmdel & 120 Manalapan Ave, Freehold, 732-462-3008 https://www.jerseyfreeze1952.com/

Fall Themed Donuts at Broad Street Dough Co.

The donuts at Broad Street Dough Co. are made fresh every single day, multiple times a day and decorated right in front of you. This Fall, there’s no shortage of Autumn themed donuts from ones topped with orange and red sprinkles, to Halloween decorated spooky donuts to the Pumpkin Walnut Cheesecake donut. No matter which donut(s) you choose to order, they’re guaranteed to be warm, fresh and packed with flavor in every bite. 2005 Route 35 North, Oakhurst / 177 Elton Adelphia Rd, Freehold (732) 531-1401 https://www.broadstreetdoughco.com/

Pumpkin Pie & Oreo Pancakes at Blue Swan Diner, Oakhurst

Just as any authentic Jersey Diner should, Blue Swan Diner has a display case filled with all your favorite desserts including Cherry Cheesecake and Pumpkin Pie! Even their breakfast menu is filled with a bunch of items that could double as dessert and will surely satisfy any sweet tooth’s cravings like the Oreo Crunch and Reese’s Peanut butter pancakes! 2116 NJ-35, Oakhurst, 732-493-2424 https://www.blueswandiner.com/

Autumn Deals

Drifthouse by David Burke, Sea Bright

VIP Loyalty Program at Drifthouse by David Burke. Their Autumn VIP Exclusive Deal offers a $50 BILL just for you! Dine with Drifthouse and receive $50 cash on every Fifth visit! Must average a $100 spend per visit. Offer good through 12/31/24. 1485 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright https://www.jerseyshoreinmotion.com/Deal/Drifthouse-by-David-Burke/VIP-Exclusive-Deal/15480

Jersey Shore InMotion Staff

Recent Posts

Get Your Scare on at These 13 Haunted Attractions This October

October is here and with that, so is Spooky Season. Grab your bravest friends and…

2 weeks ago

October Fall Events & Activities

Embrace the fall season and break free from the post-summer slump! Exciting events await you…

3 weeks ago

Pumpkin Picking in the Garden State

A staple activity to do during the Fall time with your family is pumpkin picking.…

3 weeks ago

Oktoberfest at the Jersey Shore

Get ready to immerse yourself in German culture this year and join in the festivities…

4 weeks ago

September Fall Events & Activities

If you're looking for more events to attend in addition to Apple Picking this month,…

1 month ago

14 Local Orchards For Apple Picking This Fall

An Autumn time favorite activity that all ages can do is Apple Picking. Here is…

1 month ago