A Local’s Guide to the Juiciest and Tastiest Jersey Shore Burgers

A Local’s Guide to the Juiciest and Tastiest Jersey Shore Burgers

There are few things better than chowing down on a big, juicy burger. Toasty bun, melty cheese, and maybe a few intriguing toppings – some chefs craft their burgers with a twist, and we’re not complaining!

You won’t see any chain restaurants ranked among our Jersey Shore Burger Guide, just locally owned restaurants that rock some seriously juicy, creative, and delicious burgers that are truly one of a kind!

A Jersey Shore Local’s Guide to Amazing Jersey Shore Burgers (Monmouth/Ocean Edition)

The Blended Burger at Graze Restaurant
When Chef /Owner Laercio “Junior” Chamon Jr. and his team transformed Zoe’s into Graze Restaurant over the summer we couldn’t wait to see the menu. The interior of the restaurant has been totally transformed as has the menu which prides itself on having an abundance of locally sourced ingredients. You’ll find meats, seafood and produce are often coming from just miles away in the Garden State. That being said, the Blended Burger has already earned itself a spot as the first entree on the menu. Right now, the Blended Burger has no description on their menu. This unintentional mistake has resulted in the Blended Burger having an ever-changing blend of meats and ingredients. Each time you visit you can have a different Blended Burger experience. Don’t miss this one. 151 Markham Place, Little Silver (732) 747-9988 or on the web http://graze.restaurant/menu/

Halle Burger at Asbury Festhalle & Biergarten
When it comes to burgers, you may not think of a Biergarten as having a droolworthy burger, but they proved us wrong. All hail the Halle Burger, a delicious hunk of meat topped with tangy red onion slaw, gooey Muenster cheese, tart tomato jam, and a fluffy brioche bun. They also have a killer veggie burger for vegetarian burger lovers. 527 Lake Avenue, Asbury Park (732) 997-8767 http://www.asburybiergarten.com/

jersey shore burgersBison Burger at Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits
Oh the Bison Burger, it tempts us to sing, but luckily for everyone around us, our mouths will be full. 10oz of bison (it’s like beef, but better), melted Wisconsin cheddar, frizzled onions, and bacon, all topped with homemade steak sauce. 84 Broad Street, Keyport 732-497-5555 www.oldglorynj.com/

“Jersey Burger” at McDonagh’s Pub
We’d be a little crazy not to include McDonagh’s “Jersey Burger” on our list of best burgers on the Jersey Shore. It’s a burger topped with – you guessed it – pork roll and American cheese, all piled onto warm Texas Toast. Give us a plate of that greasy goodness!  2 West Front Street, Keyport (732) 264-0999 http://www.mcdonaghs.com/

Shark Burger at Chef Mike’s Atlantic Bar & Grill
In 2012, Chef Mike Jurusz introduced the Mark the Shark Burger in honor of Mark, a young foodie and big fan of hamburgers. Mark passed away in 2010 from cancer, but his memory lives on as Chef Mike serves up the burger that was inspired by Mark. The Mark the Shark Burger is topped with bacon, white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, and half-sour pickles on a fresh-baked Joe Leone roll. Proceeds benefit the Ashley Lauren Foundation that helps families fighting pediatric cancer. We can’t think of a better reason to eat a burger right now. 24th & Central Avenue, South Seaside Park (732) 854-1588 http://chefmikesabg.com/

Dare Burger at Tuscan Bistro and Bar
Every Thursday, Tuscan Bistro Bar invites their customers to take the ultimate challenge and order the Dare Burger. Tell them how you like it cooked and how spicy you want it, but the rest is up to the chef. He’ll whip up a one-of-a-kind burger that’s made just for you. It’s a unique dining experience that is sure to impress and give you a little adrenaline rush! 1250 Hooper Avenue, Toms River  (732) 797-2570 http://www.tuscanhousenj.com

Vermunster Burger at DIVE! Coastal Bar
Head to DIVE! right across the street from the beach, grab one of their 18 beers on tap, and order the Vermunster Burger, trust us. It’s topped with house-made bacon jam and muenster cheese. Sounds like something we’d love to dive right into (pun intended). 1072 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright (732) 268-7707 http://www.divecoastalbar.com/

Gyro Burger at Burger 25
It’s not hard to believe that the burger from Burger 25 in Toms River was recently named the best in New Jersey by MSN and the Best of the Best by New Jersey readers. What is hard to believe, is that the owners, husband and wife team Steve and Denise Vetter and sister Christine Kedves, had very little experience with the restaurant business when they signed on the dotted line. But honestly, at this point, who cares. They’ve got the magic formula and we’re just happy to eat it! With so many options it is a safe bet that you’ll become a repeat customer. For your first experience, pop in on a Monday for 1/2 off Burger Night. 1611 Route 37 East (732) 270-0025 http://www.burger25.com/

BeachTavernBT Burger at Beach Tavern
Although relatively new to Monmouth Beach, Beach Tavern has been making waves with some amazing food and killer water views. This custom burger is no different. Made with a blend of brisket, short rib and sirloin it has easily ranked up as a favorite on our list. The Old Bay fries are a home run. If you happen to find yourself with a fish lover, try the Cod Po’ Boy Sandwich. Beach Tavern’s Burger Night falls every Tuesday starting at 4pm. 33 West Street, Monmouth Beach  (732) 870-8999 http://beachtavern.net/

Bison Burger at Kitch Organic
This organic and gluten-free restaurant is another locally owned business that is turning out some wonderful food. This is the Bison Burger – a beauty of a burger that features fresh ground bison that’s folded with caramelized onions. It is served medium rare with homemade garden fresh horseradish sauce, lettuce, tomato and red onion. No bun here. Just homemade sweet potato focaccia bread! Check it out and thank us later. 75 Leighton Avenue, Red Bank (732) 741-5400 http://www.kitchorganic.com/

Burger with Cheddar Cheese Suace at The Pour House
The Pour House is one of our favorite iconic Jersey Shore restaurants for a reason – for 31 years, they’ve been known for having great food and outstanding burgers. Whatever burger you decide to order, make sure it’s smothered in their homemade cheddar cheese sauce. That stuff is liquid gold. 640 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls (732) 842-4337 http://www.pourhouserestaurant.com/

Classic Burger at McGillicuddy’s Tap House
McGillicuddy’s creates a classic burger that is simply delish. They are using 10 ounces of fresh ground chuck on a fresh baked brioche bun and then the customizations start. McGillicuddy’s lets you customize their burgers every Wednesday at Build-A-Burger Night for just $10.00. Happy Hour is 4 to 7pm! 601 Main Street, Loch Arbor, NJ 07711 (732) 531-5555  http://www.mcgillicuddystaphouse.com

Jrsey Giant at Jersey Freeze
Since 1952 Jersey Freeze of Freehold has been known as the home of the best ice cream in our area. Did you know that Jersey Freeze also has one of the best burgers around? The Jersey Giant features 7 oz of beef, 2 slices of pork roll, yellow American cheese and fried onions. Served on a fresh baked hard rool. Enjoy and save room for ice cream next door! 1200 Manalapan Avenue (732) 462-3008 http://jerseyfreeze1952.com/

Kim Marie Burger at Kim Marie’s Eat & Drink Away
We know Kim Marie’s Eat & Drink Away for their
great sandwiches,  killer weekend breakfast and one of the best Happy Hours in Asbury Park. However, their burger has won us now over on more than one occasion at Happy Hour and we wanted to get the word out. The Kim Marie Burger is a choice of American, Cheddar or Swiss cheese with the option of added bacon, mushrooms and sauteed onions. We recommend you load it up with options and enjoy. 1411 Kingsley, Asbury Park (732) 774-6666 http://www.kimmarieseatndrinkaway.com/

Tavern Burger at Val’s Tavern
Val’s is known for their crispy thin-crust lobster pizza, but their 10 oz. Tavern Burger is very underrated. It’s a classic cheeseburger, served with chips and a pickle, at one of the Shore’s most family-friendly restaurants. A solid contender for the Jersey Shore’s best burgers. 123 E River Rd, Rumson (732) 842-3452 http://www.valstavern.com/

The Dubliner at McIntyre’s Pub
McIntyre’s has one of our favorite cheeseburgers – The Dubliner! It’s topped with horseradish cheddar, bacon, and grilled tomato. Nothing better than a quality burger at your favorite neighborhood bar! 1747 Hooper Ave, Toms River (732) 349-0420 http://www.mcintyrespub.com/

Double Onion Steakhouse Burger at MJ’s Restaurant

You’ve got all the classic burgers at MJ’s, but what you need to do is order one of their “amazing big burgers,” the MJ’s Double Onion Steakhouse Burger to be exact. 10oz of Angus that’s topped with melted smoky cheddar, grilled onions, pickles, crispy onion rings, and a sweet homemade BBQ sauce, it’s what little burgers dream about becoming. Head there on Thursdays for a burger spin on BYOB. For just $8.99 you can build your very own burger creation. 845 Rt. 34 North, Matawan 732-566-6220 www.mjsrestaurant.com

photo credit by Dan Trio via Google

Literally Any Burger at Barnacle Bill’s
A bit of a legend in our area as far as burgers are concerned. Handmade 10oz burgers that have kept locals coming back for years. Barnacle Bill’s is one of those places that comes up time and time again when you ask someone which place has one of their favorite burgers. Great food, drinks and riverside views. 1 First Street, Rumson (732) 747-8396  barnaclebillsrumson.com/

10oz Burger at Harborside Grill
For a Jersey Shore burger that’s juicy and tasty, all for a great price, visit Harborside Grill. Their 10oz. burger is made with lean ground beef and grilled to perfection, whether it’s rare, medium or well done, you’ll keep coming back for more. 40 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands (732) 291-0066 http://www.ahwinebar.com/restaurant/